Attack Helicopter Comparison : HAL LCH vs AW/TAI T-129 ATAK




Introduction:
We are comparing both the Helicopter due to following similarities :

  • Both helicopters belongs to the  category of Light Attack Helicopter.
  • Both aircrafts have  Twin-engine , Tandem-seat , all-weather Multi-role helicopters .
  • Both helicopters can carry a wide range of weapons including A2A ( Air-to-Air ), A2G (Air-to-Ground) missiles , rockets & a 20 mm gun .
  • HAL LCH is a  light helicopter design and developed by India’s PSU Hindustan Aeronautics Limited (HAL) while the T-129 ATAK is jointly developed by Italy’s MNC AgustaWestland and Turkey’s TAI . T-129’s design is Turish Variant of Italian AW A-129 helicopter.
  • HAL LCH’s first flight was conducted on 29 March 2010 by LCH TD-1 prototype while T129’s maiden flight took place on 28 September 2009 when T-129’s P1 prototype flew at AgustaWestland’s facilities in Vergiate, Italy.
  • HAL LCH has total order mainly for Indian Army & Indian Air Force ) while T-129 ATAK has  order  for Turkey &  Pakistan ) .
So lets begin the comparison with  various evaluation benchmarks !


Crew 
HAL LCH : 2 (tandem)
T-129 ATAK : 2 (tandem)
Unit Price 
HAL LCH :  150 crore INR appox.   ( Cheaper compared to T-129  )
T-129 ATAK :  200 crore INR
Empty weight 
HAL LCH  :  2,250 kg       ( Lighter )
T-129 ATAK : 2,350 kg
Max. takeoff weight 
HAL LCH  :  5,800 kg      ( Better )
T-129 ATAK : 5,065 kg
Useful Load Carrying Capacity :  ( Weapon Total Weight ) 
HAL LCH  : 3,550 kg      ( Better )
T-129 ATAK : 2,715 kg
ENGINES
HAL LCH  :   2 ×  Shakti 1.032 kW (1,384 shp) each   ( Slightly Better )
T-129 ATAK : 2 × CTS800-4A1,024 kW ( 1,373 shp ) each
Also-
HAL LCH uses indigenous Engine while T-129 uses American-British engine LHTEC CTS800-4N which gives the United States power to veto over any prospective export sales.

Maximum Speed 
HAL LCH  :  260-270 km / hr
T-129 ATAK : 270-280 km / hr     (Slightly Better)
Range 
HAL LCH  :  550 km       (Slightly Better)
T-129 ATAK : 530-540 km
Service ceiling 
HAL LCH  :  6,500 meters  ( Way much Better )
T-129 ATAK : 4,572 meters
Also–
HAL LCH has 2km of more service ceiling therefore it is very much operable in high altitude like LADAKH .
Endurance 
HAL LCH  :  190 mins       ( Slightly Good)
T-129 ATAK : 180 mins
Total No. of Hardpoints :
HAL LCH  :  4
T-129 ATAK : 4
Capacity to carry Air-to-Air & Air-to-Ground Missiles 
HAL LCH  :   Yes
T-129 ATAK : Yes
Main Gun 
HAL LCH  : 1 × 20 mm M-621 cannon  with total 800 rounds.
T-129 ATAK :  1× 20 mm M-197 cannon with total 500 rounds



CONCLUSION 
From the above comparison , It is clear that HAL LCH does has an edge over the T-129 ATAK in most of the specifications in its  present configurations , however upcoming  upgrades and variants can change the situation in favor of any of these two capable light attack helicopters .



Comments

Post a Comment

Popular Posts

Why don't fighter planes have guns that fire backwards?

Image
WW2 Aircraft having gun to fire backwards Guns on today's fighter aircraft are not for dog-fights.  They are there for ground attack where CAS (Close Air Support) are needed.  Today's jets are simply too fast and maneuverable to be good gunnery targets in a close in dog fight, assuming the shooter didn't take out the target with a missile at 20 miles. So supposing you did have someone on your tail and you DID have a rear firing gun.  What then?  Think of reversing your car at high speed and trying to keep the road centered in your mirror.  The slightest twitch of your jet would send any bullets off target, and twisting/turning is the best dog fight defense you can have in a gunnery dog fight.  You would need a turreted gun with tracking radar and perhaps a second crew to man it.  Too heavy a penalty for a very rare usage.  In short, rear facing guns are simply impracticable on today's fighter jets. ANOTHER REASON: It is not that...
Read more

Why does the Indian Special Forces prefer Israeli weapons like the Tavor Tar-21 over the American M4?

Tavor has become the staple firearm of Indian Special Forces units with Full Length Barrel variants in service with Primary Special Operations Units while shorter barrel variants are in service with various SWAT and Commando units in India. Tavor has been increasingly favored over other weapon systems and specially the M4 Carbines which has been the staple weapon for various Special Operations Forces and Counter-Terrorism Organisations. The reason why Indian Special Forces prefer Israeli Tavor Family of Rifles over the American M4 Carbines are many , some of which I will discuss below : > Bull-Pup Configuration :  Tavor Family of Rifles took the Bullpup configuration to a newer level eliminating those problems which earlier plagued the Bullpup firearms. Bullpup Configuration means that the receiver , magazine and Bolt Carrier is placed behind the Pistol Grip thus helping the weapon to reduce its overall length while retaining the actual barrel length. This configuration is a...
Read more

What is the difference between Fighter,Attack And Strike Aircraft???

                            Fighter aircraft Fighter aircraft  are sometimes  air superiority  aircraft or mainly  multi-role  aircraft nowadays.  These aircraft are primarily designed to overpower and outmaneuver enemy aircraft to obtain and maintain airspace control. These aircraft typically have more powerful, sophisticated radars allowing them to detect enemy aircraft earlier, and launch counter mesures such as air-to-air missiles on them.  They are mostly lightweight but having powerful engines, giving them a very high thrust-to-weight ratio and an abundance of power. Lastly, they  have bubble canopies affording excellent visibility in many directions. The most typical modern example of this is the Su-30 MKI And Rafale of Indian Air-force.                                 ...
Read more